FREE: Find out what promotions could add to your business, in about a minute. FREE for your business See Your Revenue Forecast →
See Your Revenue Forecast

How to Track Marketing Channels That Bring New Customers

Gym owner reviewing results to track marketing channels that bring in new members

To track marketing channels, give every channel its own link or code, tie each sale or claim back to the link that produced it and compare buyers and revenue by source instead of clicks or likes. Once every channel is measured the same way, you can see which ones bring new customers and move your time and budget to them.

This guide shows a simple setup any local business can run, what to measure and how to turn the numbers into decisions.

Why Is It So Hard to Know Which Channel Works?

Most local businesses guess. They ask “how did you hear about us?” and get “Google, I think” or “a friend, maybe Instagram.” People don’t remember, and the last thing they saw usually gets the credit.

Each platform also reports its own numbers its own way. Social shows reach and likes. Email shows opens. Ads show clicks. None of these tell you how many people paid you. And because open counts are affected by mailbox privacy features, even email opens are only a rough guide.

The fix is to measure every channel by the same thing: did a real customer buy or claim something, and how much was it worth?

What Should You Measure for Each Channel?

Track these for every source, every month:

  • Clicks or views: how many people saw the offer
  • Purchases or claims: how many acted on it
  • Conversion rate: purchases divided by clicks
  • Revenue: dollars from that source
  • New contacts: first-time emails and phone numbers
  • Redemptions: how many actually came in
  • Cost per new customer: what you spent divided by new customers

Revenue and new customers are the two that matter most. The rest help explain why a channel is up or down.

How to Track Marketing Channels Step by Step

  1. List every channel you use. Website, email, text, Facebook, Instagram, Google Business, paid ads, partner businesses, flyers, signs and events.
  2. Create one link per channel. Your Instagram bio gets one link, your Facebook ad gets another, each partner gets their own. Never reuse a link across sources.
  3. Use a different QR code for each printed piece. The flyer at the coffee shop and the table tent in your lobby should point to different links.
  4. Run the same offer everywhere at first. If every channel carries the same offer, differences in results come from the channel, not the deal.
  5. Record redemptions at the counter. A sale that never gets redeemed tells a different story from one that does. Note the spend at redemption if you can.
  6. Review weekly, decide monthly. Look at results every week, but give a channel at least a month before cutting it.

What Does a Channel Report Look Like?

Here is a real example from the Promo Engine homepage. One med spa ran a “Back to Spa” offer and tracked it channel by channel:

  • Website: $12,590
  • Banners: $6,050
  • Email: $5,920
  • Promo Engine network: $1,835
  • Chat: $440

That was $26,835 from one offer. And because every channel was tracked separately, the spa knows its website drives twice what email does. That is a decision you can act on: put the offer on the website first, keep email in the mix and spend less time on chat.

How Do You Calculate Cost per New Customer by Channel?

Divide what you spent on a channel by the number of new customers it brought in. Include your time if it’s significant. Here is a hypothetical month:

  • Paid social ad: $400 spent, 8 new customers, $50 each
  • Printed flyers: $150 spent, 3 new customers, $50 each
  • Partner coffee shop: $0 spent, 12 new customers, $0 each
  • Website popup: $0 extra spent, 30 new customers, $0 each

Now compare that with what a new customer is worth. If a new customer spends $250 in their first year, a $50 cost is fine. If they spend $60, it isn’t. Either way, the partner and the website are doing the heavy lifting, and that is where more effort pays off. To see what this could look like for your business, run a free Revenue Forecast.

For a full method, see how to measure the ROI of a promotion.

What If a Customer Sees Your Offer in Several Places?

Many people see an offer more than once before they buy. They might notice a Facebook post, get an email two days later and buy from the email. Link tracking gives the credit to the link they actually used, which is the channel that closed the sale.

That is fine for most local businesses. Just keep it in mind when you read the numbers. A channel with few direct sales can still be doing useful work by making people aware of the offer. If you cut social posts and email sales drop the following month, social was helping. The safest test is to change one channel at a time and watch the total, not just that channel’s line.

How Do You Turn Channel Data Into Decisions?

Once you have a month or two of numbers, sort each channel into one of three groups:

  • Do more: channels with low cost per new customer and steady revenue. Post more often, add more partners, improve the popup.
  • Fix or test: channels with lots of clicks but few buyers. Try a different offer, a clearer headline or a shorter page.
  • Cut: channels that cost money and bring almost no buyers after a fair test.

Change one thing at a time so you know what made the difference. If you run several locations, compare the same channel across locations too; see how multi-location brands attribute revenue across sites.

Channels that often surprise owners are the free ones: website visitors, partners and your own list. Our guides on how to get new customers without more ads and local cross-promotion ideas show how to grow them.

Mistakes to Avoid

  • Judging by clicks or likes. Count buyers and revenue.
  • Sharing one link everywhere. Then every sale looks like it came from the same place.
  • Different offers in each channel at the start. You can’t tell if the channel or the offer made the difference.
  • Ignoring redemptions. A sale is good. A visit where they also spend more is better.
  • Cutting too soon. One slow week doesn’t make a bad channel.

How Promo Engine Helps

Promo Engine tracks every offer, purchase and redemption by source, so you know exactly what is driving your promo revenue:

  • Trackable Links. Create one link per source (ads, social, partners, print) and see clicks, purchases, conversion and revenue for each. See trackable links.
  • Direct Link. Every promotion has its own link, which counts as Direct in your results.
  • Promotion results. Revenue, purchases, items, redemptions and new contacts, with tabs for Email, Popups, SMS, Trackable Links and Triggers. See results and attribution.
  • Redeem with spend. Staff redeem a voucher by name, email or confirmation number, and can enter what the customer spent, which shows as Redeemed Revenue.
  • Reports. Promotions, Redemptions, Locations and Newsletters reports with filters and CSV export for your bookkeeper.

Clear tracking changes how owners spend. Dallas Karting Complex owner Kevin had tried daily deal sites before. With Buy Now offers sent to his email list and social followers, he brought in $100,700 in a little over four months and earned a return of nearly 63x on the program’s cost. See how the platform works or book a demo.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I track which marketing channel brings in customers?

Give every channel its own link or QR code, run the same offer across channels and compare purchases, revenue and new contacts by source. Record redemptions at the counter so you know which sales turned into visits.

Is asking customers how they heard about us enough?

It helps, but it is unreliable. People forget, and the last thing they saw usually gets credit. Trackable links and codes give you numbers you can trust.

What is the most important marketing metric for a local business?

Revenue and new customers by channel. Clicks, likes and opens can explain why a channel is up or down, but they don’t tell you whether it paid off.

How long should I test a marketing channel before cutting it?

Give most channels at least a month with a consistent offer. Review results weekly, but make cut or keep decisions monthly so one slow week doesn’t mislead you.

How do I calculate cost per new customer?

Divide what you spent on a channel in a period by the number of new customers it brought in. Compare that with what a new customer typically spends in their first year to see if the channel is worth it.

Know what works

See exactly which channel brings your new customers

Find out what your promotions could earn, or talk with us about tracking every offer, purchase and redemption by source.

See Your Revenue Forecast
Book A Demo

Free Revenue Forecast

See What Promotions Could Earn Your Business, Before You Spend a Dollar

Enter your website and we'll build your custom Revenue Forecast in about a minute. It's built from your real services and prices, and 10+ years of real results from merchants on our platform.

What's inside your forecast

  • ✓
    Your projected revenue and new customersMonth by month, based on your customer list and website traffic.
  • ✓
    4 promotions built for your businessUsing the services and prices on your website, with suggested discounts.
  • ✓
    Your 12-month promotion calendarWhat to run and when, timed to the months that sell best.
  • ✓
    A preview of your offer pageSee how a promotion could look with your branding.
  • ✓
    What you'd pay vs. what's possibleYour platform cost side by side with your projected sales.

Built on real results, not guesses

75,000+promotions analyzed
1.2M+customer orders
10+ yrsof real results
  • 1Enter your website
  • 2Answer 3 quick questions
  • 3Get your Revenue Forecast
See Your Revenue Forecast

Free, with no credit card needed.

Psst....

See your Revenue Forecast

Enter your website and in about a minute we’ll show you which promotions fit your business, what they could earn, and when to run them.