The Business Growth Engine · Episode 3
Investor playbook
With Darrin Shamo, former CMO of Coupang and Offerpad · Executive Advisor at TCV
Darrin Shamo has led marketing and growth at some of the best-known consumer brands of the last two decades: Zappos through its acquisition by Amazon, Coupang in South Korea, DoorDash during its hypergrowth years and Offerpad as it went public. His core belief is simple. Marketing amplifies a great product. It can’t replace one.
Darrin explains why he often moved marketing dollars into product guarantees and service, how Zappos found the customers who attract its best buyers, and how DoorDash decided where each marketing dollar should go. He shares what local business owners can do with little or no marketing budget, where to start with AI this year, and what he looks for as an investor in the first 10 minutes of a pitch.
Investor & Advisor · Executive Advisor at TCV
Darrin led marketing at Zappos, guided the team through its acquisition by Amazon and served on Zappos’ internal board. He went on to be CMO of Coupang, VP of Growth and Marketing at DoorDash and CMO of Offerpad. Today he is an executive advisor at the growth-equity firm TCV, serves on boards and invests in seed to Series B companies, especially ones building with AI. Disclosure: Darrin serves on the board of Biggest FAN Holdings Inc, the company behind Promo Engine.
Chris: Hey everybody, welcome to the Business Growth Engine today. I’m Chris Lange, your host. I’m excited for our guest. Today, he’s helped build and scale some of the best-known consumer brands of the last 2 decades. Darrin Shamo led marketing at Zappos, guided the team through its acquisition by Amazon, and served on Zappos’ internal board. He went on to be chief marketing officer at Coupang, the company often called the Amazon of South Korea, and then led growth and marketing at DoorDash during its hypergrowth years and was CMO of Offerpad here in Arizona as it went public. And today he’s an executive advisor at the growth equity firm TCV. He sits on boards, he invests in early-stage companies, especially ones building with AI. Full disclosure, Darrin is also on the board of Biggest Fan Holdings, Inc., which is the company that is behind Promo Engine. So I’ve had a front row seat to how he thinks. Darrin, welcome to the show.
Darrin: Glad to be here.
Chris: Hey, great. Hey, let’s dive into this. So first question, you’ve been CMO, you’ve been a growth leader in San Francisco, like what’s been the thread that connects those jobs?
Darrin: You know, it doesn’t really matter what the industry is. It’s been on-demand, it’s been e-com, it’s, you know, we’ve had some real estate experience. Really, the consumer behavior is the same. You get the product right, you get conversion right, you get your CPLs right, and you generate growth. And so every company goes through a similar scale lifecycle. They face a lot of the same issues. And so once you’ve seen the movie once, it’s easy to know what’s coming around the corner. And so, you know, building strategy, building playbooks for each of those companies has been pretty much the same regardless of their industry.
Chris: So let’s look at Zappos for a second. Zappos was famous for customer service and marketing. So, you know, what did you learn there that still shapes how you build a brand today?
Darrin: Yeah, I mean, so much of what you need to focus on as a marketer, and this is probably one of the bigger problems with a lot of marketing engines and marketing organizations, is they think in terms of just driving traffic. And if you stop from the time they hit the site, if you stop at the site, you’ve really missed the big problem, which is conversion rate and retention rates. And so if you focus your energy, quite often I found that the best investment was put back into the product, and not just the product itself, I mean, not just, you know, what you’re selling, but the whole packaging around the product. How do you make the consumer feel like the product is foolproof. It is so reliable, it is so in their corner that they would want to try it and continue to use it. So much of what I focused on was putting that investment— if I’ve got, you know, $100 million a year to spend in marketing, I might find that $20 million of that is better spent in building product guarantees and improving the overall quality of the product. So that I have the retention rate so I don’t have to continually drive CAC in a certain direction to solve the problem. If you have strong retention rates, your CAC can go up 10%. And it’s still a win for the business. So, you know, just rethinking the way that the economics work from the start to the finish has been a big needle mover for these different businesses that I’ve been plugged into.
Chris: So if we can lean into that for just a second, if you’re a local business or any business at that matter, and you’re wanting to invest in what you’re talking about, invest in the product, making the product better for the consumer, whoever the user is, how would you suggest or recommend people, you know, do that when they’re trying to understand customer voice, when they’re really wanting to know exactly how can I make this product better? Any suggestions on how a business would go about finding out how to make that product or improve that product to be a better market fit?
Darrin: Well, the first is you need to understand the sensitivity between the dollar upfront in marketing and the dollar spent in the product. If you don’t know what you’re spending, what your CAC is, how efficient your dollars are spent by market, by platform, then it’s not really going to help you much. You need to understand that in context to what’s happening on the conversion side, how sticky the product is, how well it’s working. Once you kind of have a good understanding of that, then you can start playing with that a little bit and saying, okay, I’m going to reallocate a portion of my funds back to a better guarantee or a better service offering or free shipping or whatever it is. If you can focus on the quality of that product and then you measure that end-to-end. So what is the LTV from my first dollar spent on an impression to all the way down to how it’s trickling down to conversion rate and long-term hold of that product and retention, continuing to come back and purchase again. So the more that you understand that end-to-end picture, because you’ve tested every aspect of the funnel, the better you are at driving the ultimate result. So, you know, I’ve found that the more time I spend, as is the case with most marketers, you’re constantly trying to drive efficiency in your channels. Constantly trying to drive efficiency in the platforms and in the geographies that you’re working with. But that is all table stakes. You’ve got to do that. Everybody’s got to do that. But if you can think end-to-end and you say, all right, hold on, let’s stop and look at the overall offering, I’m having these hiccups here. Where, yeah, my CAC’s coming down because we’ve got some efficiency, but it doesn’t seem to be resulting in stronger conversion, or it doesn’t seem to be resulting in better LTV. If you’re looking at all of that end-to-end, because you should, you’re going to find some of those problems.
Chris: You know, I actually, I love the conversation. As you know, we’ve worked with over 4,000 businesses, you know, over the course of the past couple years, and so much of their pain point is marketing and they’re always trying to figure out where do I spend my money, you know, where do I invest my time and energy when it comes to marketing? So incredible wise words for businesses to understand, you know, that relationship there. Let’s look a little bit more into Zappos here. So you led Zappos marketing team through the Amazon acquisition, which is incredible. So what did that experience teach you about building a company worth buying?
Darrin: Yeah, I mean, everything about Zappos was customer first. How do we make the customer say wow when they’ve had a transaction with us? When you start to think in terms of ultimately your objective is just to blow the mind of the consumer, then really you’re getting to a good place where marketing is just amplifying a really great message. And so you have the benefit of, you know, when you’re operating in a Zappos environment, you have the benefit of just having the world’s best product and service. Everybody wants it, everybody’s talking about it. And so now you just need to get out of the way and amplify the message. And so the opportunity becomes, how do I do this in a way that is getting it in front of all of these people and putting them in the position where they’re holding the megaphone. And so a lot of our efforts were focused on getting people— for example, we did this best customer analysis early on in the company where we found that our best customers were customers that, you know, they purchased 5 times a year and they typically didn’t write reviews, but they read a lot of reviews. And so we recognized, well, if we’re going to drive our funnel efficiency efficiently, we need to find the particular customer profile that does write reviews. So we started acquiring not our best customers, but the customers that would help us acquire our best customers. And having that whales and minnow analysis where we can figure out, hey, what are the customers that are driving the types of behavior that are going to attract the highest margin customers? And then focusing on those equally. You also find that there’s a subset of customers that abuse the policies that actually become a drain for the overall product offering for your customer base. Well, you start doing less of those behaviors. You start changing the product, changing the way that you market. If they skew a specific demo, you’re starting to— or psychographic profile, you’re starting to move away from that. So the more intel you have on your customer base and understanding who are your best and what drives your best, the more you can shape your strategy around that. So ultimately a program like that, and I had applied all that same type of logic to every company that I’d gone to. Once you start doing that, you start to be able to really improve the efficiency of the dollars coming in and going out. Because you’re now targeting the right people.
Chris: No, absolutely love that. Let’s look at DoorDash here for a second. Now, DoorDash had maybe a growth problem when you first got there. Like, what did you do to change that? What did you do first?
Darrin: Well, when I came in, they were on a down round, which is always a great thing when you’re coming in as a growth and marketing lead. Always the most exciting part is, you know, your effort, you know, directly can help and shape your particular ownership stake. So it’s a great place to be in. But I wouldn’t say they had a growth problem. They were growing, they were driving, but they had some real challenges as every company does. You know, we call them accordion problems. You push a little bit, it creates a little bit of friction and causes some part of the system to break. You push a little bit, you solve that problem, you generate more growth and demand, and it breaks another part of the system. And so anytime you’re dealing in any business with those growth constraints and those growth challenges, it’s gonna break other parts in your funnel. It’s just the nature of it. The added complexity of DoorDash’s 3-sided marketplace made things more exciting and more challenging. Because as you would grow a certain aspect of the business, it would cause some other part of the problem, some other system to break. So for example, you generate a lot of customers to come in. Well, now you don’t have enough Dashers to be able to deliver the product, and that creates a poor product experience, which then ultimately decreases your LTV. And so the whole process became a little bit of a challenge. We had to kind of go back and say, what are the real drivers to the business? And one of the biggest growth engines was our, you know, the merchants. How do we drive the merchants? So we had a DAC, we had a CAC, but we didn’t really have a MAC, a merchant acquisition cost. And we thought, well, what if we spend a little bit more time and focus on driving the right types of merchants and building in exclusive relationships with those merchants and using that to drive demand— a dollar spent there ends up being much more efficient than a dollar spent just simply bringing customers into the funnel.
Chris: Yeah. And when you’re referring to DoorDash merchant, you’re referring to like a restaurant, a business that is carrying DoorDash, and you guys would be trying to get exclusive relationships with them to have the DoorDash service. Is that—
Darrin: That’s right, yeah. So that was part of the challenge. The other part was it’s very complex when you have lots of different regional managers that are running specific metros. The person running the New York market competing with the San Francisco RGM, and they all want their demand. They want to be able to drive their growth, but you only have so many marketing dollars. So understanding that, hey, you know, you’ve got all of these different people coming and saying, how do I get more growth? If you let everybody have the growth that they need or that they want, you’re 300% of your budget. So the key to understanding that problem was really breaking it down into portfolios. And so if I knew that the dollar that is going into like our San Francisco market is producing on an index 1.4, or 140% of the average, and a market like Dallas is coming in at 60%, then I know that there’s gotta be a floor that I place so that I can maximize overall yield for the company. And so a dollar spent in the San Francisco market would yield more than a dollar spent in the Dallas market, but obviously we’ve gotta grow the Dallas market. So we’d set floors to help sustain a certain level of growth, but allow for the maximization of yield by putting dollars in the right place. And so just coming up with a system for how we manage our overall budget so the entire company can effectively achieve its growth rates while the RGMs and the particular metros are getting the support that they need.
Chris: So let’s look at kind of localized businesses here. So if I’m a local business that’s tuning into this, like from, you know, DoorDash, what did you learn about local businesses that every small business owner should know?
Darrin: Well, I mean, it becomes a little bit of a challenge because really there’s the corporate side, which is how do I maximize yield, and then there’s the local business owners, which is I don’t really care about the broader corporate, I just need to grow my business. And so what I would say is when corporate is looking at it from a yield maximization perspective, become sexy. I mean, you need to be able to produce the metrics that will give you the support that you need to grow that business. That means you need to have tight operations, you need to have— so that you have a positive customer experience. You have people coming in the door that want to continue to come in the door. You need to have low friction to get in the door. So there’s got to be those— it tends to be that those local businesses that are going to get a lot of corporate support in like a system like this, they’re doing the things that are right to improve the economics of the corporate investment. And so the more that they can do a lot of the organic lift to get people in, that’s going to effectively reduce the CAC and improve the LTV. So that when the corporate side is looking at it, they’re like, hey, actually, we’re seeing a lot of efficiency here. So where I see problems typically is that like a regional manager or a local business will look at their businesses and say it’s not working because marketing’s not doing their job. But if they do a lot of the organic lift for the marketing side, then effectively the blended rate is going to look better for them. Because they’re already doing a portion of the work. And so as a result, they’re going to get a lot more of the available marketing dollars because it’s looking more favorable in the portfolio. So the biggest challenge I see is, you know, SMBs or the smaller side, the businesses that are trying to build their local presence, leaning too much or providing too much of an excuse of, hey, the reason why it’s not growing is I’m not getting outside support.
Chris: So if we were looking at this kind of tactical approach here, you obviously, you guys have to be extremely tactical, particularly you’re talking about a, you know, billion-dollar company. So what did you find were the kind of growth tactics working with a billion-dollar company that would work for a business with no marketing budget or a very limited marketing budget? Any specific tactics that come to mind on how do we continue to grow on a very limited marketing budget?
Darrin: Yeah, well, let’s just break down what’s happening on the marketing side from a corporate perspective. You have a lot of stuff that’s happening on the content side to improve the organic growth rates. So, you know, do I have enough content? Do I have the right type of content? Is it interesting? Is it showing up in the right places in front of the right people? And then there’s the paid side of that. Am I amplifying it in the right ways, in an efficient way to be able to get it in front of people? That’s typically what happens on the marketing side is maximize organic, maximize paid after organic is kind of set in place. From the local perspective, there’s a whole other layer of organic effort that they can do. The more they do that, the more the blended rate swings in their favor. So if I’m doing all paid advertising, then maybe my CAC’s at $5. If 50% of my volume coming inbound is organic and I’m paying relatively little minus some headcount, then, you know, it’s going to be half of that. If I’ve got 50% of my effort, my inbound traffic coming through organic efforts, then my blended rate comes down to effectively half what it would have been. And if that’s the case, now it looks very appealing from an investment standpoint. Because now relative to others, it is my best investment to maximize yield. So if you look at it from a blended perspective, it is what is all the work that’s being done on the content side in building affinity for the product? And getting it out in the right locations. And so a lot of that has even changed over the years. I mean, you know, it’s been 10 years since I was at DoorDash and, you know, they’re a lot more sophisticated even now than we were back then, and same is true with all of these platforms and services, but part of it is that the landscape has dramatically changed. And so the way that you drive traffic and the way that you do it efficiently, like for example, if you’re not building a good presence on the content side, if you’re not doing a lot more with AI right now, you’re really missing a major portion of that. And remember, AI is pretty much just looking at— they don’t get caught up in marketing speak. They are looking specifically at reviews and some of the content that explains the product, but they’re not going to get caught up in the sizzle. So you really need to, again, focus on product if you’re going to do well in basically AI engine responses.
Chris: No, gosh, and I love it. I mean, we could spend a whole other episode just talking about marketing tactics and marketing strategy and what’s available today. So very, very wise detail here, but let me switch a little bit to the investor’s view. So you invest from seed to Series B, you know, $100,000, million-dollar-plus. Walk us through what you look for in the first 10 kind of minutes of a pitch?
Darrin: Yeah, I mean, the first is how well they know the product. Second is how well established and well connected, but really how well the management team works together. Do they have the chops to actually run it? I actually find it to be a little bit of a problem, and this is not the case for everyone, but for most of the businesses that I’m looking at, if the CEO or the SLT is overly focused on marketing. Because marketing is an amplification tool, it’s not really the product itself. I want this person— the leadership team should really be obsessed about how do I make the product, how do I establish product-market fit? And therefore I need to have the right product first that aligns with the market. So do they have that? Do they understand that? And then I also, you know, you’re obviously looking at the economics. You want to get into the data room. You want to see what’s actually happening, how well it’s performed over time, what are some of the big hangups to their growth, do they need the growth right now, or is there a more efficient way for them to scale that without having to surrender a lot of equity? You know, most people that are in this space are not equity hungry. They’re just trying to help make sure they’re tapped into a business that would really fundamentally be changed if they had the capital to spin up their growth engine. Some just don’t need it, and it can be a problem by plugging yourself in prematurely or unnecessarily.
Chris: So you’ve also said that you’re most excited about AI-heavy companies. Like what separates a real AI business from an AI hype? Like what’s the differentiators there?
Darrin: Well, I mean, I look primarily at the track record, but are these people actually going in? Do the leaders understand how to tap into AI to be able to improve OpEx? Are they finding ways to reduce their— or really activate their existing headcount? Is there, for lack of a better word, is the ROI per employee going up because they’ve effectively adopted AI? Or do they have, you know, are they applying physical AI in an efficient way so that you can see the overall OpEx improve? Do you see efficiency in overall conversion rate as they are applying it? There are some companies that are native AI, meaning they’re building their own LLMs. They’re doing a lot of the work and they’re finding pockets of improved efficiency. I do think over time a lot of these are going to consolidate in just a few like we see with every industry, but for now I’m primarily focused on the track record. What are they doing with it? How efficiently are they— what are we seeing in terms of efficiency as they are applying it? And that also tells you a lot about how strong the SLT team is in operations and managing the resources that they have. If they can’t really demonstrate that they’re very effective in managing the logistical resources, they’re probably not very efficient in managing the capital resources.
Chris: Yeah, no, it makes sense. So, okay, final question. I know we’re running out of time here. What should a local business owner do with AI this year? Like, what should they ignore? What should they start with? What advice would you give a local business owner about where they should be starting and thinking about their focus on AI?
Darrin: I would first say, look around you at your team. What do they do for you? And what can be employed with leveraging AI to increase the throughput of the existing employee base that they have? They should be looking at bots and employing a lot of different bots to solve specific challenges and problems that they have day to day in their operations. They should be tasking their teams to come up with playbooks that will enable them to increase their throughput, and they should have a demonstrated improvement in their throughput. I mean, I’m a big believer in OKRs as an incentive structure for corporations to really drive collective growth. They should have a clear sense of what they’re going to do with it and what their forecast for improvement is, and that should be something that everyone is reviewing regularly. If they’re not improving their overall throughput, then it stands to reason that there might be a drain that needs to be addressed.
Chris: Well, gosh, Darrin, incredible information you’ve given just me personally. So many things to think about and to maybe even reframe with how I’m approaching things even in my business, but can’t thank you enough for being on here today. Hopefully in the future, there’s so many things we can do on other episodes I’d love to focus you on. So maybe we could have you back at another episode. But guys, appreciate you tuning in today. Darrin, thank you so much for joining us on the Business Growth Engine. We’ll see you guys next time. Thanks everybody.
Promo Engine builds, distributes and tracks promotions that bring new customers through your door, without spending a dime on ads.
Book a demo