To learn how to price a promotion that makes money, start with your cost to deliver the service, then set a discount that still leaves profit on the first visit. Find your break-even discount, count the add-ons and return visits a new customer brings, and put limits on quantity, timing and use. A smaller discount with a clear deadline usually earns more than a deep one that runs forever.
Here is the math, with worked examples you can copy for your own business.
Why Do So Many Promotions Lose Money?
Most money-losing promotions fail for the same few reasons:
- The discount is bigger than the margin. Half off sounds great until you realize your cost to deliver the service is more than half the price.
- Someone else takes a cut. Daily deal sites often keep a large share of an already discounted price.
- There are no limits. Unlimited vouchers with no expiration fill your best days with your lowest-paying customers.
- Nobody counts what happens next. If you never track add-ons or return visits, you cannot tell a good promotion from a bad one.
Our article on why most promotions fail and how to fix them covers the strategy side. This guide is about the numbers.
How to Price a Promotion: The Basic Math
You need three numbers for the service you plan to promote:
- Regular price: what a customer pays today.
- Cost to deliver: staff pay for that service, products used, supplies and card processing fees. Leave out rent and other fixed costs you pay either way.
- Margin: regular price minus cost to deliver.
Say you sell a 60-minute massage for $120. The therapist earns $40 for the session and supplies and fees cost about $5, so your cost to deliver is $45 and your margin is $75.
- 20% off ($96): you keep $51 per visit.
- 30% off ($84): you keep $39 per visit.
- 50% off ($60): you keep $15 per visit.
- 50% off on a site that keeps half ($30 to you): you lose $15 on every visit.
The same service can be a solid promotion or a money pit depending only on price and who takes a cut.
Find Your Break-Even Discount
Divide your margin by your regular price. In the massage example, $75 divided by $120 is 62.5%. Any discount deeper than that loses money on the first visit. A safe working rule is to stay well under half of your break-even discount, which here means about 30% or less.
Count What Happens After the First Sale
The first visit is rarely the whole story. Add up the likely extras:
- Add-ons during the visit: an upgrade, a retail product, food and drinks or game cards.
- Return visits at full price: even if only one in four new customers comes back twice, that changes the math.
- Referrals and gifts: a happy customer brings a friend who pays full price.
Back to the massage. At $84, you keep $39 on the first visit. If one in four buyers rebooks twice at full price, that adds about $37 of margin per original buyer, so each promotional sale is worth roughly $76 in margin. That is a promotion worth running.
What Discount Should You Offer?
There is no single right number, but these ranges are a sensible starting point for local businesses:
- 10% to 20% off: for regulars and loyal customers who would come anyway. Keep it light.
- 20% to 30% off: for new-customer intro offers, where you want a real reason to try you.
- Added value instead of a discount: a free add-on, an extra session in a package or a bonus gift card for a later month. These often cost you less than they are worth to the customer.
- Two-for-one: works when the second item costs you little or brings a new customer. See why BOGO deals work.
- Bundles: package a high-margin item with a lower one and price the set below the separate total. Our guide to bundle pricing shows how.
How to Protect Your Margin With Limits
Limits let you offer a stronger deal without risking your calendar or your profit:
- Quantity cap: sell 100 vouchers, not unlimited. A cap also adds urgency.
- Per-person limit: stop one buyer from taking ten.
- Short sale window: 48 to 72 hours with a clear end time.
- Valid days: make the offer good on weekdays or slower hours, so it fills empty time instead of replacing full-price visits.
- Expiration: give buyers enough time to use it, but not so long that you lose track of what you owe.
- New customers only: for intro offers, limit them to first-time guests.
Not sure what a well-priced offer could add for your business? Run a free Revenue Forecast and see which promotions fit and what they could earn.
How Should Pricing Change by Business Type?
- Spas and med spas: higher tickets leave room for a modest discount on a package or series. One med spa on Promo Engine has a $456 average purchase, so even a light discount on a treatment package brings in real money.
- Salons: discount the service that brings people in, such as a first cut or a treatment, and let color and retail carry the margin.
- Gyms: discount the first month or a class pack, never the ongoing membership rate.
- Restaurants: food cost is high, so lean on weeknight dining credit and added value. See restaurant promotion ideas that protect your margins.
- Family entertainment centers: price admission or tickets to sell volume, then earn on food, drinks, game cards and party upgrades.
How Do You Know If Your Promotion Price Worked?
After the sale ends, check:
- Revenue and number of purchases
- Margin per sale after your cost to deliver
- Redemption rate and add-on spend at redemption
- How many buyers were new customers
- How many came back within 60 to 90 days
For a full walkthrough, read how to measure the ROI of a promotion. As Elements Laser Spa owner Paul put it: “We love being able to drive revenue without mass discounting.”
How Promo Engine Helps
- Clear pricing on every offer: each Buy Now offer shows what the customer pays next to the regular value, and you choose whether to show the discount. See promotions.
- Products with set prices: keep one product catalog with prices per location, so offers use the right numbers.
- Built-in limits: set a maximum per person, quantity limits on coupons, start and end dates, and expiration by date or days after purchase.
- No marketplace split: payments go to your own Stripe account, and fees are shown with a worked example so you know what you keep.
- Redeemed revenue: staff can record what a customer spent on top of the voucher at redemption, so you see the add-ons your price brought in.
- Results per promotion: revenue, purchases, redemptions and new contacts for each offer and channel. See results.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I calculate the right discount for a promotion?
Subtract your cost to deliver the service from the regular price to get your margin, then divide the margin by the price. That gives your break-even discount. Stay well below it so the first visit still makes money.
Is 50% off ever a good promotion?
Only when your margin is high, the quantity is capped and you have a clear plan to bring buyers back at full price. For most local services, 20% to 30% off or added value earns more.
Should I discount or add value?
Added value, such as a free add-on or a bonus session, often costs you less than a straight discount and protects your regular price. It works well for spas, salons and gyms.
What limits should every promotion have?
Set a quantity cap, a per-person limit, a clear sale end date and an expiration date. Consider valid days, such as weekdays only, so the offer fills slower times.
How do I know if my promotion was priced well?
Compare revenue and margin per sale with your cost to deliver, then track add-on spend and how many buyers return within 60 to 90 days. A good promotion pays on the first visit or clearly on the second.
Price It Right
Run promotions that make money on day one
See which offers fit your business and what they could earn at the right price, then talk it through with our team.


